Just like with every other state, living in Florida requires one to brace themselves for challenges that come with hurricane season. Depending on the severity and damage that is anticipated from the hurricane, a lot of Floridians can either board up their homes or put hurricane shutters up. With both methods, there comes the choice of impact windows vs hurricane shutters. The two systems do provide protection; however, they vary in aesthetics, cost, convenience, and overall value. This guide will help you understand whether impact windows or hurricane shutters will be more suitable for you.
Understanding the Basics
What Are Impact Windows?
Impact windows, also referred to as hurricane windows, are a blend of strong resistant glass and another layer of strong glass. In case of breakage, the strong interlayer makes sure that the shattered glass does not fall apart. Unlike others, these windows cannot be removed and protect the exterior permanently. Not only does this pose as protection from the outside world, but it helps in preventing UV rays from coming in and allows no intruders.
What Are Hurricane Shutters?
Hurricane shutters are a form of coverings that go over windows and are utilized to stop the entry of debris and very strong winds. These are available in many options, such as rolling, accordion, Bahama, and storm shutters. Unlike impact windows, shutters must be unfolded and put in position before the onset of winds and storms. After the storm is over, these shutters can safely be taken down.
Key Factors to Consider
1. Protection & Safety
– Impact Windows: Offer continuous protection without the need for manual setup. They are rigorously tested to withstand hurricane-force winds and impact from debris.
– Hurricane Shutters: Provide excellent protection when properly installed and closed. However, if not deployed correctly or in time, they offer no protection.
Winner: Impact Windows (due to 24/7 protection)
2. Convenience & Ease of Use
– Impact Windows: Always in place, requiring no additional effort when a storm approaches.
– Hurricane Shutters: Must be manually deployed before each storm, which can be time-consuming and physically demanding.
Winner: Impact Windows
3. Aesthetic Appeal
– Impact Windows: Maintain the home’s natural look and provide clear, unobstructed views.
– Hurricane Shutters: These can be bulky and affect a home’s exterior appearance, depending on the style.
Winner: Impact Windows
4. Cost & Investment
-Impact Windows: Higher upfront costs, but increase home value and reduce insurance premiums.
–Hurricane Shutters: More affordable initially but do not add as much resale value to the home.
Winner: Tie (short-term savings with shutters vs. long-term investment with impact windows)
5. Energy Efficiency & Noise Reduction
– Impact Windows: Improve insulation, reduce energy costs, and minimize outside noise.
– Hurricane Shutters: Do not improve energy efficiency or reduce noise when not in use.
Winner: Impact Windows
6. Insurance Savings
– Many Florida homeowners qualify for discounts on their home insurance with either option.
– Impact windows typically yield **higher insurance discounts** because they provide permanent protection.
Winner: Impact Windows
Which Option is Best for Your Home?
If you’re looking for a long-term investment that enhances safety, aesthetics, and energy efficiency, impact windows are the best choice. However, if cost is a primary concern and you don’t mind manual preparation, hurricane shutters can still offer strong protection at a lower initial price. Impact windows offer more value while hurricane shutters are a viable and budget-friendly option, impact windows provide superior convenience, protection, and added home value, making them the better investment in the long run.
Get a Free Consultation
If you’re considering upgrading to impact windows or hurricane shutters, contact Eco Choice Windows & Doors today for a free consultation. Our product specialist will help you choose the best solution to keep your home safe and secure year-round.