One of the most significant decisions you make while choosing impact windows for your home in Florida is deciding on the frame material. Vinyl and aluminum are the leading two contenders, but how do you choose which one to use?
Both products have pros and cons, so it is important to be aware of the differences prior to investing. The right decision is based on various factors, including energy efficiency, strength, upkeep requirements, and cost. In this article, we will analyze the pros and cons of vinyl versus aluminum impact windows in order to make an informed decision.
What Are Vinyl Impact Windows?
Vinyl impact windows are made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a durable plastic material that is very insulating and easy to maintain. The windows are designed to withstand Florida’s extreme weather patterns, including hurricanes and torrential storms, while also providing improved energy efficiency in the home.
Advantages of Vinyl Impact Windows
✔ Increased Energy Efficiency – Vinyl frames are a natural insulator, which keeps your home cooler in Florida’s hot summers. This can mean lower energy bills. *(Reference: U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver Guide)*
✔ Low Maintenance – Vinyl will not corrode, peel, or require constant repainting like aluminum.
✔ Cost-Effective – Vinyl windows tend to be less expensive than aluminum impact windows.
✔ Improved Noise Reduction – The soundproofing quality of vinyl can reduce outside noise, silencing your home.
✔ Corrosion Resistance – Perfect for Florida’s coastal, salty, and humid environment, as it won’t rust or corrode.
✔ UV Resistance – Vinyl windows resist fading and weakening from the intense Florida sun.
Downsides of Vinyl Impact Windows
✘ Less Structural Integrity – Vinyl is less durable than aluminum, resulting in heavier frames on large openings.
✘ Less Color Options – White and neutral-colored vinyl windows are the norm, with fewer color choices than aluminum.
✘ May Warp Under Extreme Heat – High-quality vinyl can endure Florida sun, but low-quality versions warp in the long term.
✘ Heavier Frames – Due to the additional structural need, vinyl window frames are heavier than aluminum frames.
What Are Aluminum Impact Windows?
Aluminum impact windows are very robust and long-lasting, making them a popular choice among homeowners who desire utmost security and durability for their windows. The windows have a sleek, modern look and are suitable for homes that require large glass surfaces.
Benefits of Aluminum Impact Windows
✔ High Strength & Toughness – Aluminum frames are extremely resilient and are adequate for large-sized window openings as well as strong winds.
✔ Thin & Contemporary Looks – Aluminum windows contain thinner profiles, thus occupying lesser space within and giving sleek modern looks.
✔ Decade-Long Duration – Maintained nicely, aluminum windows may last several decades.
✔ Warps & Cracks Resistant – Aluminum does not warp, crack, or break down under extreme heat, unlike vinyl.
✔ Enhanced Customization – Available in a wide range of colors and finishes to match your home’s aesthetic.
✔ Fire-Resistant – As a natural element, aluminum is fire-resistant, giving your home an extra protection barrier.
Downsides of Aluminum Impact Windows
✘ Insufficient Insulation – Aluminum is a conductor, and therefore it conducts heat more effectively, which can result in higher energy costs. *(Source: ENERGY STAR, Window Performance Ratings)*
✘ Higher Maintenance – Aluminum windows have the potential to rust along coastal areas if they are not well coated or maintained.
✘ Costlier – For the most part, aluminum impact windows cost more than vinyl.
✘ Less Soundproofing – Aluminum frames are less sound-reducing than vinyl.
✘ Condensation Problems – Since aluminum is a heat conductor, condensation may occur on the interior side of the window, creating the possibility of moisture problems.
Which Impact Window Material is Best for You?
In choosing between aluminum and vinyl impact windows, think about these issues:
– Energy Efficiency : If saving on energy bills is the top priority, vinyl is the better choice due to its improved insulation properties.
– Strength & Durability: If you need windows for big openings or windy areas, aluminum is the better choice.
– Coastal Considerations : Vinyl is the better choice for beachfront homes due to its rust-resistance, whereas aluminum needs a protective coating to prevent rust.
– Aesthetic Wishes: Aluminum gives a shiny, modern look with more scope for personalization, whereas vinyl typically is available in understated shades.
– Cost Vinyl is relatively inexpensive with great long-term value, yet aluminum is expensive with great durability.
– Climate Considerations: Florida’s humidity and heat lead to quick heating of aluminum, yet vinyl windows keep indoor temperature disturbances at bay.
Other Considerations In Making Impact Window Decisions
– Hurricane Protection: Vinyl and aluminum impact windows both comply with Florida’s high hurricane-resistant requirements.
– Installation Process: Proper sealing and energy efficiency can only be ensured through professional installation.
– Warranties & Lifespan: Both vinyl and aluminum windows have various warranty options available, so inspect what is included before buying.
Final Thoughts
Both vinyl and aluminum impact windows are excellent choices for Florida homeowners in need of protection from hurricanes and harsh weather conditions. Your final decision will essentially be based on your home’s specific needs, design factors, and budget constraint.
Vinyl impact windows suit homeowners who desire energy efficiency, minimal maintenance, and affordability. On the other hand, aluminum impact windows are suitable for those who desire strength, sleek appearances, and durable longevity.
If you’re still unsure which option is best for you, contact Eco Choice Windows & Doors for a quote with one of our product specialist.
Looking for the best impact windows for your Florida home? Contact us today for a free consultation and find the perfect solution for your home’s safety and efficiency!
